Title: The Whitening of the American Teaching Force: A Problem of Recruitment or a Problem of Racism?
Abstract: The best of the Negro teachers will largely go because they will not and cannot teach what many white folks will long want taught (W.E.B. Du Bois, 1954). The newspapers headlines say that teachers are fleeing urban because they fear the students. The Blacks and Latinos I know are not fleeing. We're trying to get into classrooms, but there are so many things stopping us (Felipe M., a 45-year-old bilingual Latino college graduate who tried to enter the teaching field for 15 years). OVER THE LAST 10 YEARS, I HAVE PARTICIPATED IN THE PREPARATION OF SOME 2,000 new teachers. I have found little correlation between the requirements to enter a credential program and one's likely effectiveness as a teacher. Due to a series of barriers that fail to predict good teaching, while excluding minorities, America's school children, soon to be a majority non-Anglo, suffer needlessly from the absence of Latino, Asian, African-American, and Native American teachers. Moreover, some urban classrooms have no permanent teachers at all. Our vocabulary is inadequate when it comes to words that group together who are not white. Minority are not really a minority in relation to the world's population, or even in the public school population in many cities. Concerning the subject being studied, however, the experience of all groups differs from that of whites as a group. Therefore, I resort at times to available, yet inadequate, terms such as nonwhite and people of color. The Problem Restated 40% of the public school students in the U.S. are African-American, Latino, Asian, and Native American (U.S. Department of Education, 1999). During this same period, less than 10% of the teachers come from those groups (NCES, 2001). The discrepancies are even more dramatic in the central cities, where Latino and African-American youth have made up the majority of the student populations since 1981 (Schaerer, 1996). Further whitening of the teaching force is projected primarily from the composition of those currently enrolled in teacher preparation programs: 85% are white, seven percent African-American, four percent Latino, less than one percent Asian/Pacific Islander, and .5% Native American (AACTE, 1994). Scholars have noted that the absence of teachers deprives African-American and Latino students of role models and creates a distorted social reality for all children (Witty, 1982). As a Los Angeles teacher, who is one of the few African-American adults in her school, observes, It's a good thing to have role models of the same ethnicity; it's very important. I know all the Black students from kindergarten all the way up; there's just this automatic attraction. There are times when kids not even from my class stop and have conversations with me, whether it is a casual thing or they are having a problem (ARC, 1999). Moreover, rarely noted are the following equally significant problems: 1. The absence of African-American and Latino teachers deprives many urban school children of the opportunity to have a permanent teacher. Teacher education has historically failed to staff urban schools or to accept responsibility for this failure (Haberman, 1991). 2. School teaching is a rapidly growing, stable job for college graduates. This job is one of the most widely available in many urban communities, but not to half the African-American, Latino, and Asian college graduates who seek to enter it. Thus, parents within the most unemployed sections of the U.S. population are deprived of one of the best jobs in their communities--teaching their own and their neighbors' children. 3. White teachers, widely acknowledged to be in need of multicultural training, are deprived of role models that might enable them to interact successfully with children from cultures different from their own (Goodwin, 1997; Ladson-Billings, 1991; Sleeter and Grant, 1991). …
Publication Year: 2005
Publication Date: 2005-09-22
Language: en
Type: article
Access and Citation
Cited By Count: 36
AI Researcher Chatbot
Get quick answers to your questions about the article from our AI researcher chatbot