Title: Defeat and Victory in “The Battle of Maldon”: The Christian Resonances Reconsidered
Abstract: D E F E A T A N D V I C T O R Y I N " T H E B A T T L E O F M A L D O N " : T H E C H R I S T I A N R E S O N A N C E S R E C O N S I D E R E D RICHARD HILLMAN York University E v e r since J. R. R. Tolkien's erudite flyting at Byrhtnoth for his ofermod and its tactical consequences,1 commentators have been forming ranks on one side or the other. The case for Byrhtnoth's posthumous cashiering has been vigorously countered with more or less ingenious excuses, even claims for canonization. The etymological, historical, and literary evidence has been put through a variety of critical sieves without decisive results. The contro versy arises from an intractable ambivalence: even as he appears to be blaming Byrhtnoth for the defeat, the "Maldon" poet is elevating him to heroic stature.2 D. L. Scragg, in his recent edition, argues that the eulogistic tenor of the poem can remain comfortably in suspension with the hero's faults, which in his view actually extend to "hubris."3 But most commen tators are evidently not comfortable; they thirst for some sort of resolution — in effect, for an underlying principle of unity. Given the fragmentary condition of the poem, it might be the better part of valour to abandon this desire. But it can also be satisfied, I believe, more completely than has been recognized. Rosemary Woolf has aptly described the poem as "an heroic story in which paradoxically it is better to lose than to win."4 In the follow ing pages, I should like to examine the poet's presentation of Byrhtnoth and his followers in light of a celebrated paradox: " Qui enirn voluerit animam suarn salvam facere, perdet earn: qui autem perdiderit animam suam propter me et evangelium, salvam earn faciet.',!i The few previous attempts to read the poem in Christian terms have not met with wide acceptance. Scragg, typically, concludes: "there is little evidence that the poet intended any form of allegory or moral teaching in the narrow sense."6 Perhaps it is precisely the narrowness of this criticism that has failed to convince. Thus Morton W. Bloomfield finds an allusion to patristic portrayals of the soul after death.7 N. F. Blake argues for a close parallel to /Elfric's life of St. Edmund.8 In both cases, the specific relevance of the analogue is difficult to establish, while the argument is not supported by direct confrontation with the poem's central issue. Yet, as Blake points out, saints and martyrs all depend on and recapitulate a common original, E n g l is h St u d ie s in C a n a d a , x i, 4, December 1985 Christ himself. Surely the overtly Christian elements in the poem — Byrhtnoth 's prayers and the insistent (if formulaic) contrast between English Christians and Viking heathens — justify a broader exploration in terms of that primary analogue. Important to Scragg's argument against the relevance of saints' lives is their emphasis on passivity at the moment of martyrdom.9 Thus St. Edmund, following Christ's example, disarms himself: . . . awearp his waepna; wolde geaefenlaxan Cristes gebysnungum, ]> e forbead Petre mid weapnum to winnenne wi5 pa, waelhreowan Iudeiscan.10 But we should not forget that this feature is a vital part of the homiletic design, intended to hold up an ideal model of Christian behaviour in an age that took violent retribution for granted. When we detach Byrhtnoth's history from the saint's-life paradigm, we lighten the burden of exemplum. We no longer have the story of an imitator of Christ, but rather of an heroic figure whose struggle in his Christian cause may remind us of, and gain meaning from, Christ's own. W. F. Bolton's recognition of Byrhtnoth as miles Christi seems to me important, although his application of the concept is, again, disappointingly narrow and tenuous: he perceives only a moral allegory involving Christ's temptations in the wilderness." There is...
Publication Year: 1985
Publication Date: 1985-01-01
Language: en
Type: article
Indexed In: ['crossref']
Access and Citation
Cited By Count: 19
AI Researcher Chatbot
Get quick answers to your questions about the article from our AI researcher chatbot