Title: “Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists” A content analysis of the news coverage of George W. Bush’s speeches on the War on Terror in the context of American nationalism
Abstract: In existing literature on the War on Terror, the role of the news media has received
ample attention. Especially considering the controversy surrounding the Iraq War, the
way that the mainstream news media framed the war has been extensively scrutinized
in academics. These studies have primarily focused on the way these news frames
influenced the American public perception of the War on Terror. Among communication
scientists, there is a broad consensus that the way news organizations cover important
issues in their outlets has a profound effect on how the public understands these issues.
Whereas a number of frames have been studied extensively, the role of nationalism has
remained fairly overlooked. An examination of the use of the nationalism frame by news
outlets therefore is a valuable addition to existing literature. It provides an insight into
the potential impact this frame had on the American public in the context of the War on
Terror. In this study, three newspapers were compared in terms of the extent to which
they used the nationalism frame in their news coverage during the War on Terror. These
newspapers were The New York Times, the New York Post, and the Saint Louis Post-
Dispatch. More specifically, the extent to which these newspapers adopted nationalist
statements from President George W. Bush’s speeches was measured by conducting a
quantitative content analysis of these newspapers. There is consensus among scholars
that during the War on Terror, the press depended too much on information presented
to them by government officials. The news media have been blamed for abandoning
their role as watchdog of the government during the War on Terror. It is argued in this
study that nationalism played a big role in the news framing of the Iraq War in the
media. To measure nationalism in the newspapers, three concrete characteristics of
American nationalism were identified on the basis of existing literature. These were
exceptionalism, vindicationism, and othering. It was concluded that all three elements
were adopted to a much higher extent by the conservative newspaper, the New York
Post, than by the other two newspapers that are generally perceived as liberal. Besides,
it was found that the nationalism frame was much more pervasive during the Iraq War,
than during the Afghanistan War. All in all, readers of the conservative newspaper were
significantly more likely to be influenced by nationalist sentiments in their perception of
the War on Terror than readers of the liberal newspapers.
Publication Year: 2018
Publication Date: 2018-08-19
Language: en
Type: article
Access and Citation
AI Researcher Chatbot
Get quick answers to your questions about the article from our AI researcher chatbot