Title: Projecting the ‘Chineseness’: Nationalism, Identity and Chinese Martial Arts Films
Abstract: AbstractWushu, also known as Kung Fu, is a traditional Chinese martial art. It also symbolises the strength of the Chinese and their pride in their history. Wushu came to be associated with Chinese nationalism after China's various defeats at the hands of foreign imperialist powers at the turn of the twentieth century. This relationship has been further strengthened through martial arts films. In the first half of the twentieth century, martial arts films helped to construct national identity among the Chinese. They also facilitated the development of Wushu, making it a symbol of indigenous virtue and strength. From the late 1960s, influenced by a defensive strain of nationalism, Chinese film-makers began to adopt a new approach to the portrayal of Wushu. Martial arts films were endowed with political and cultural significance, and evolved as a unique representation of Chinese nationalism. Several decades later, martial arts films still retain at their core a sense of ‘Chineseness'. From Bruce Lee's Fist of Fury to Donnie Yen's IP Man, Chinese martial arts films have demonstrated not only the important place of Wushu in Chinese nationalism, but also the influence of nationalism on Chinese cinema.Keywords:: WushuChinese martial arts filmidentitynationalismcinema Notes 1.CitationRenan and Girardet, Qu'est-ce qu'une nation?, 26. 2.CitationLin, “The Development of Wushu Societies.” 3.CitationAnderson, Imagined Communities, 44. 4.CitationLu and Yeh, “Introduction,” 2. 5. Kez Wallis, “Bruce Lee Representative of Chinese Nationalism and Masculinity,” http://academicotaku.wordpress.com/2011/06/01/bruce-lee-representative-of-chinese-nationalism-and-masculinity/ (accessed October 20, 2013). 6.CitationGreen and Svinth, Martial Arts of the World: An Encyclopedia of History and Innovation. 7.CitationGraff and Higham, A Military History of China. 8.CitationZhou, The History of Chinese Martial Arts. 9.CitationHamm, Paper Swordsmen, 12; CitationTeo, Chinese Martial Arts Cinema, 17.10.CitationLu and Fan, Sport and Nationalism in China.11.CitationLu and Li, “The Development of Wushu.”12.CitationHuang, “The Development of the Jingwu Society.”13.CitationLi, “The History of the Jingwu Society.”14.CitationMa, “The Rise and Fall of the Jingwu Society.”15.CitationLu and Li, “The Development of Wushu.”16.CitationLuo, The History of Sport in China, 1840–1926.17.CitationLee, “Far Away, So Close”; CitationZhang, Chinese National Cinema.18.CitationYe, “The First Chinese Martial Arts Film.”19.CitationLi and Jubin, A History of Chinese Silent Films, 239.20.CitationLi, “Kung Fu”; CitationWang, “A Critical Interrogation,” 51.21.CitationZhang, Chinese National Cinema, 40.22.CitationLi, Chinese Cinema.23.CitationGuo, “A Brief History.”24. The Han Chinese ethnic group accounts for the majority of the population in China.25.CitationZhang, Chinese National Cinema, 57.26. Ibid.27.CitationLee, “Far Away, So Close.”28.CitationYang, “Zhang Zhijiang Dianji Guoshuguan.”29.CitationHarrison and So, “The Background to Language Change.”30.CitationZhang, Chinese National Cinema, 92.31.Fong Saiyuk and Wu Waikin's Three Attempts at Wudang Mountain Fong Saiyuk, The Sequel (1949); Fang Shiyu's Nine Battles at Emei Hill (1949); How Fong Sze Yu Undertook a 10,000 Mile Journey for Vengeance (1949); and Fong Sze Yu Sets Fire to Hong-Yun Monastery (1949).32.CitationKlein, “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon.”33.CitationGreen and Svinth, Martial Arts of the World: An Encyclopaedia of History and Innovation. Volume I: Regions and Individual Arts, 530.34.CitationZhang, Chinese National Cinema, 41.35.CitationLee, “Far Away, So Close”; CitationLi, “Kung Fu.”36.CitationNathan and Ross, The Great Wall, 34.37.CitationHarding, “China's Changing Roles,” 188.38.CitationCheng, “Hong Kong's Watershed.”39. Ibid.40.CitationYep, “Cultural Revolution in Hong Kong.”41.CitationCheng, “Hong Kong's Watershed.”42.CitationLi, “Kung Fu.”43. Ibid.44.CitationLee, “Far Away, So Close,” 518.45.CitationDresser, “Fists of Legend.”46.Fist of Fury, Directed by Lo Wei, produced by Raymond Chow, Orange Sky Golden Harvest, 1972.47.CitationTasker, “Fists of Fury,” 444.48.CitationLi, “Kung Fu.”49. Ibid.50.CitationShu, “Reading the Kung Fu Film,” 53.51. Wallis, “Bruce Lee Representative of Chinese Nationalism and Masculinity.”52.CitationLi, “Kung Fu,” 519.53.CitationCheng, The History of Chinese Cinema.54.CitationFu, The History of Sport in China,1949–1979.55.CitationMa, Crossing Swords.56.CitationCheng, The History of Chinese Cinema.57.CitationXie, “Celluloid Century,” 62.58.CitationLi, “History and Reality.”59.CitationLei, The History of Chinese Martial Arts Films.60.CitationGong, “Mysterious Buddha.”61. Central China Television, “Wulinzhi,” http://www.cctv.com/program/ljsy_new/14/62/index.shtml (accessed October 10, 2013).62.CitationWang, “The Special Form of Martial Arts Films.”63.CitationLi, “Kung Fu.”64. Michael Lai, “The Great Wall Will Never Fall Down,” opening theme of The Legendary Fok, Rediffusion Television, 1981.65.CitationHao, The History of Sport in China, (1980–1992).66. Ibid.67. Ibid.68.CitationWang, Chinese Kung Fu.69.CitationHao, The History of Sport in China, (1980–1992), 190–1.70.CitationZhou, The History of Chinese Martial Arts; National Martial Arts Research Academy, The History of Chinese Martial Arts.71.CitationHillman, “Chinese Nationalism.”72. The incident occurred when the US Navy forced a Chinese-registered regular container ship, the Yinhe, to stop in the international waters of the Indian Ocean and accused the ship's crew of carrying materials for chemical weapons to Iran. The ship was searched and no such items were found. In spite of this, the US government refused to apologise. The incident was viewed as a total national humiliation and sparked an outpouring of Chinese nationalist sentiment.73. A mid-air collision occurred between a US Navy EP-3 surveillance plan and a People's Liberation Army Navy interceptor fighter jet near Hainan Island on April 1, 2001.When the American crew was eventually released by the Chinese authorities, an outraged Chinese public not only protested against the US government, but also accused the Chinese government of weakness and kowtowing to the West.74.CitationTownsend, “Chinese Nationalism,” 121.75.CitationShambaugh, “Containment or Engagement,” 205; CitationZhao, “Chinese Nationalism.”76.CitationLiu, “Restless Chinese Nationalist Currents,” 206.77.CitationGeng, “Dragon on Foreign Land.”78.CitationLee, Wuxia Film, 29.79. Yi Liao, “Fearless: The Most Successful Hong Kong Movie in 2006,” http://news.xinhuanet.com/newmedia/2006-12/25/content_5528009.htm (accessed October 15, 2013).80.Yip Man, Directed by Wilson Yip, produced by Raymond Wong, Mandarin Films Distribution Co. Ltd, 2008.81.CitationChen, “Yip Man 2's Box Office.”82. Joy Fang, “Quick Take: Ip Man 2,” http://www.asiaone.com/print/News/Latest%2BNews/Showbiz/Story/A1Story20100429-213082.html (accessed October 30, 2013).83.CitationChen, “Yip Man 2's Box Office.”84.CitationWang, “A Critical Interrogation,” 52–3.85. Wallis, “Bruce Lee Representative of Chinese Nationalism and Masculinity.”86.CitationChan, “The Global Return,” 4.87.CitationTeo, “Promise and Perhaps Love.”88.CitationChung, “Hollywood Domination”; CitationLarson, “Zhang Yimou's Hero”; CitationLevitin, “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, Hero, and House of the Flying Daggers”; and CitationZhang, “Hero.”89.CitationTeo, “Promise and Perhaps Love.”90.CitationWang, “A Critical Interrogation.”Additional informationNotes on contributorsLu ZhouxiangLu Zhouxiang is a lecturer in Chinese Studies in the School of Modern Languages, Literatures and Cultures at the National University of Ireland, Maynooth. His main research interests are modern Chinese history, nationalism and globalism, and comparative studies between the West and China in the field of sport.Qi ZhangQi Zhang is a lecturer in the School of Applied Language & Intercultural Studies at Dublin City University, Ireland. Her main research interests are intercultural communication, Chinese literature and sociolinguistics.Fan HongFan Hong is Winthrop Professor in the School of Social Sciences at The University of Western Australia. Her main research interests are in the areas of culture, politics, gender and sport.