Abstract: The effects of externally applied, resonant magnetic field perturbations on tokamak plasmas are discussed. An analytical model assuming tokamak ordering and narrow islands clarifies the conditions under which error fields are amplified or diminished by self-consistent effects. A strong amplification of error fields near marginal tearing stability is found to broaden the range of parameters over which deleterious tearing effects are seen. Three-dimensional numerical solutions indicate that saturated tearing mode island widths can be sensitive to the presence of small nonaxisymmetric perturbations. It is argued that the theoretical conclusions are consistent with observations in error compensation experiments, and are also consistent with observations of enhanced growth for locked modes.