Title: Cash Transfers and Temptation Goods: A Review of Global Evidence
Abstract: No AccessPolicy Research Working Papers5 Aug 2014Cash Transfers and Temptation Goods: A Review of Global EvidenceAuthors/Editors: David K. Evans, Anna PopovaDavid K. Evans, Anna Popovahttps://doi.org/10.1596/1813-9450-6886SectionsAboutPDF (1.1 MB) ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack Citations ShareFacebookTwitterLinked In Abstract: Cash transfers have been demonstrated to improve education and health outcomes and alleviate poverty in various contexts. However, policy makers and others often express concern that poor households will use transfers to buy alcohol, tobacco, or other "temptation goods." The income effect of transfers will increase expenditures if alcohol and tobacco are normal goods, but this may be offset by other effects, including the substitution effect, the effect of social messaging about the appropriate use of transfers, and the effect of shifting dynamics in intra-household bargaining. The net effect is ambiguous. This paper reviews 19 studies with quantitative evidence on the impact of cash transfers on temptation goods, as well as 11 studies that surveyed the number of respondents who reported they used transfers for temptation goods. Almost without exception, studies find either no significant impact or a significant negative impact of transfers on temptation goods. In the only (two, non-experimental) studies with positive significant impacts, the magnitude is small. This result is supported by data from Latin America, Africa, and Asia. A growing number of studies from a range of contexts therefore indicate that concerns about the use of cash transfers for alcohol and tobacco consumption are unfounded. Previous bookNext book FiguresreferencesRecommendeddetailsCited byУДОСКОНАЛЕННЯ ОРГАНІЗАЦІЙНИХ ЗАСАД АДРЕСНОЇ ПРОДОВОЛЬЧОЇ ПІДТРИМКИ НАСЕЛЕННЯПРОДОВОЛЬЧІ РЕСУРСИ, Vol.10, No.1925 December 2022Alleviating time poverty among the working poor: a pre-registered longitudinal field experimentScientific Reports, Vol.12, No.114 January 2022Do various dimensions of food security affect household welfare differently? An empirical investigation of India's national food security actLetters in Spatial and Resource Sciences, Vol.15, No.322 July 2022High Hopes: Experimental Evidence on Financial Inclusion and the Transition to High School in KenyaEconomic Development and Cultural Change, Vol.2201 November 2022Debunking Myths about Poverty: Social Actor Representation of the Participants of the Canceled Ontario Basic Income Pilot ProjectJournal of Poverty, Vol.26, No.64 August 2021Investigating preferences between cash and in‐kind transfers among the food subsidy beneficiaries of IndiaJournal of Public Affairs, Vol.22, No.325 January 2021The Role of UBI in Mitigating the Effects of Psychosocial Stressors: A Review and ProposalPsychological Reports, Vol.125, No.431 March 2021The basic income: Initiating the needed discussion in industrial, work, and organizational psychologyIndustrial and Organizational Psychology, Vol.14, No.414 December 2021Consumption Patterns under a Universal Basic IncomeBasic Income Studies, Vol.16, No.28 February 2021Sustaining Planetary Health in the AnthropoceneDoes Welfare Receipt Change Consumption on Health among Older Families? The Case of ChinaJournal of Aging & Social Policy, Vol.124 May 2021Poverty, depression, and anxiety: Causal evidence and mechanismsScience, Vol.370, No.6522Does 'Manna from Heaven' help? The role of cash transfers in disaster recovery—lessons from Fiji after Tropical Cyclone WinstonDisasters, Vol.44, No.322 January 2020Supplemental Income Program Design: A Cluster-Randomized Controlled Trial to Examine the Health and Wellbeing Effects on Older Adults by Gender, Duration, and Payment FrequencySocial Science & MedicineThe Effect of Egocentric Taste Judgments on Stereotyping of Welfare Recipients and Attitudes Toward Welfare PolicyJournal of Public Policy & Marketing, Vol.39, No.110 May 2019(Nie)przewidziane konsekwencje? Reforma edukacji oraz reforma nauki i szkolnictwa wyższego realizowane przez rząd PiS wobec obietnicy realizacji państwa dobrobytu1 January 2020Work disincentive perceptions and welfare state attitudes: A survey experiment in South KoreaGovernance, Vol.32, No.35 February 2019The Political Theory of Universal Basic IncomeAnnual Review of Political Science, Vol.22, No.1Conditional vs unconditional cash transfers: a study of poverty demographics in PakistanEconomic Research-Ekonomska Istraživanja, Vol.32, No.117 September 2019La Renta Básica Universal basada en la evidenciaPolítica y Sociedad, Vol.55, No.320 November 2018Cash transfers to enhance TB control: lessons from the HIV responseBMC Public Health, Vol.18, No.122 August 2018Social Safety Nets Promote Poverty Reduction, Increase Resilience, and Expand Opportunities23 July 2018Recognizing and Leveraging Politics to Expand and Sustain Social Safety Nets23 July 2018Who Benefited from Burundi's Demobilization Program?World Bank Economic Review, Vol.32, No.216 July 2018Resource rents, universal basic income, and poverty among Alaska's Indigenous peoplesWorld Development, Vol.106Analyzing the Performance of Social Safety Net Programs22 March 2018Savings defaults and payment delays for cash transfers: Field experimental evidence from MalawiJournal of Development Economics, Vol.129The Consumption of Household Goods, Bargaining Power and their Relationship with a Conditional Cash Transfer Program in PeruJournal of International Development, Vol.29, No.42 February 2017Comparing Cash and Voucher Transfers in a Humanitarian Context: Evidence from the Democratic Republic of CongoWorld Bank Economic Review, Vol.31, No.124 July 2017Public Works as a Productive Safety Net in a Post-Conflict Setting: Evidence from a Randomized Evaluation in Sierra Leone11 April 2016Income Timing, Savings Constraints, and Temptation Spending: Evidence from a Randomized Field ExperimentSSRN Electronic JournalCash Transfers and Labor Supply: Evidence from a Large-Scale Program in IranSSRN Electronic JournalComparing Cash and Voucher Transfers in a Humanitarian Context: Evidence from the Democratic Republic of Congo17 December 2015Medicalizzazione della devianza, controllo sociale e social workSOCIOLOGIA DEL DIRITTO, No.1Theories of Poverty Traps and Anti-Poverty PoliciesThe World Bank Economic Review, Vol.29, No.suppl 116 April 2015Generating Employment in Poor and Fragile States: Evidence from Labor Market and Entrepreneurship ProgramsSSRN Electronic JournalResources-to-Cash: A Cautionary Tale from MongoliaSSRN Electronic JournalLeveraging Social Protection Programs for Improved Nutrition: Summary of Evidence Prepared for the Global Forum on Nutrition-Sensitive Social Protection Programs, 2015SSRN Electronic JournalDevelopment in a Multi-Polar World: The Post-2015 AgendaSSRN Electronic Journal View Published: May 2014 Copyright & Permissions Related RegionsAfricaEast Asia & PacificLatin America & CaribbeanSouth AsiaRelated TopicsFinance and Financial Sector DevelopmentMacroeconomics and Economic GrowthPoverty Reduction KeywordsCASH TRANSFERSTEMPTATION GOODSIMPACT EVALUATIONCONSUMPTION PDF DownloadLoading ...